🚨 Why Different Interest Rates Based on Credit Score Are Fair
Today Korean Economic News for Beginners | 2025.09.30
0️⃣ Rational System Reflecting Risk, Core Mechanism for Financial Stability
📌 "Higher Rates for Low Credit Score" Unfair? No, It's Essential to Prevent Financial Crisis
💬 When getting a bank loan, people with high credit scores get low interest rates of 3-4% per year, but people with low credit scores must pay high interest rates of over 10% per year. You might feel it's unfair that interest rates differ so much based on credit score when borrowing the same amount. However, this is a rational pricing method that reflects the bank's risk of not getting their money back. What would happen if everyone got the same low interest rate? People who pay back loans well wouldn't bother borrowing, and only people who have trouble paying would rush to get loans. This phenomenon is called "adverse selection," and it can eventually cause bad loans to increase rapidly and put the entire financial system at risk. The 2003 credit card crisis and the 2008 U.S. subprime mortgage crisis actually happened through this exact mechanism. Financial authorities and economists emphasize that "credit-based interest rate differentiation is a core mechanism that protects financial stability."
1️⃣ Easy Explanation
When banks decide loan interest rates, the most important thing they look at is 'Can this person pay back the borrowed money on time?' Your credit score is a number that shows the answer to this question.
A high credit score means you have paid back borrowed money faithfully in the past, paid credit card bills on time, and have no late payment records. From the bank's perspective, there's little risk of losing money when lending to such a person, so they can apply a low interest rate. For example, if someone with a credit score in the 900s borrows 100 million won, they would pay 3.5% interest per year, which is 3.5 million won in interest annually.
On the other hand, a low credit score means there are past late payment records, you're borrowing from multiple places, or you have too much debt compared to your income. From the bank's perspective, there's a high risk of not getting their money back when lending to such a person, so they apply a high interest rate to compensate for the risk. Even borrowing the same 100 million won, if your credit score is in the 600s, you might have to pay 10% interest per year, which is 10 million won in interest annually.
Here's an important question: "Wouldn't it be fair to give everyone the same low interest rate?" Theoretically it might seem so, but in reality, big problems occur.
Let's imagine giving everyone a low interest rate of 3.5% per year. What would happen? People with high credit scores who can pay back money well would think "Why should I borrow money?" and wouldn't want to take out loans. Meanwhile, people with low credit scores who have trouble paying back money would rush to get loans thinking "I can't miss such a cheap interest rate."
As a result, the proportion of "risky borrowers" among the bank's loan customers would keep increasing. Over time, many of these people would fail to pay back the money, and the bank would suffer big losses. When these losses accumulate, the bank becomes troubled, and in severe cases, it can turn into a financial crisis.
Actually in Korea, there was a credit card crisis in 2003. At that time, card companies issued cards and provided cash services recklessly without properly checking credit scores. As a result, millions of people couldn't pay their card bills, card companies became massively troubled, and the entire financial system shook. The government had to inject emergency bailout funds, and many people became credit defaulters and suffered economic hardship.
A bigger example is the 2008 U.S. subprime mortgage crisis. American banks gave home loans at low interest rates even to people with low income and credit scores. At first there seemed to be no problem as home prices rose, but when home prices started falling, millions of people couldn't pay back their loans at the same time. This led to the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers and a global financial crisis, and the world economy was badly hit.
In the end, interest rate differentiation based on credit score "looks unfair" but is actually a safety device that protects the financial system and prevents bigger crises.
2️⃣ Economic Terms
📕 Credit Score
A credit score is an indicator that analyzes an individual's financial transaction history and shows in numbers their 'ability and willingness to repay money.'
- In Korea, NICE Credit Rating and Korea Credit Bureau (KCB) evaluate scores from 1 to 1,000 points.
- They comprehensively consider loan repayment history, credit card usage patterns, late payment status, total debt amount, etc.
- 900+ points is premium, 700s is good, and 600 or below is considered low credit.
📕 Additional Interest Rate
Additional interest rate is the extra interest that banks add to the base rate, reflecting the borrower's credit risk.
- If the base rate is 3%, people with high credit get an additional rate of 0.5% for a total of 3.5%.
- People with low credit might get an additional rate of 7% for a total of 10%.
- The additional rate includes the bank's operating costs, expected profit, and the risk that the borrower can't pay back (credit risk).
📕 Adverse Selection
Adverse selection is a phenomenon where only bad trading partners remain in the market due to information asymmetry.
- In the loan market, if everyone gets a low interest rate, only high-risk borrowers will gather.
- Good borrowers don't take debt, only bad borrowers try to get loans, and the bank's bad loans increase rapidly.
- It's an economic concept similar to only 'lemons (defective products)' remaining in the used car market.
📕 Moral Hazard
Moral hazard is when people protected from risk lose caution and engage in riskier behavior.
- If you give low credit borrowers low interest rates, they think "since the interest is cheap anyway" and increase their debt more.
- Their willingness to repay weakens and they borrow from other places too, creating a 'debt snowball' phenomenon.
- It's similar to driving less safely after getting insurance.
3️⃣ Principles and Economic Outlook
✅ Economic Rationality of Credit-Based Interest Rate System
Let's analyze why interest rate differentiation based on credit score is economically rational.
First, the principle of risk and return balance works. Banks play a 'financial intermediary' role, lending money received from depositors to borrowers. If a borrower can't pay back, the bank must bear that loss, and ultimately depositors' money becomes at risk too. Therefore, banks apply high interest rates to risky loans and low interest rates to safe loans to balance risk and return. This is a basic principle that operates in all markets. It's the same logic as expecting high returns when investing in risky stocks and receiving low interest on safe deposits.
Second, it encourages efficient capital allocation. A high credit score signals that the person uses money productively and has the ability to pay it back on time. By having more capital flow to such people through low interest rates, the productivity of the entire economy ultimately increases. Meanwhile, people with low credit scores make loan decisions more carefully due to high interest rates, preventing reckless debt increase. With Korea's household debt exceeding 1,900 trillion won in 2025, this mechanism is becoming even more important.
Third, it's a core mechanism for maintaining market trust. If banks ignore credit scores and lend indiscriminately, healthy borrowers would wonder "Why should I faithfully repay my debts?" This destroys the credit culture of the entire society. Conversely, when high credit scores come with clear rewards of low interest rates, people are motivated to manage their credit well. This virtuous cycle becomes the foundation that sustains trust in the financial market.
The credit-based interest rate system may seem unfair personally, but it's an essential mechanism that protects the entire system.
✅ Risks of Information Asymmetry and Adverse Selection
Let's look at why information asymmetry is dangerous in the loan market and how adverse selection occurs.
First, borrowers know their repayment ability better than banks do. This is information asymmetry. Banks judge based on credit scores, income certificates, and asset details, but borrowers themselves know more accurately information like "I might lose my job soon," "I have hidden debts elsewhere," or "Actually this business has a high chance of failing." If everyone gets low interest rates, people with this 'risky information' will actively try to get loans.
Second, when adverse selection mechanisms work, the market becomes distorted. Economist George Akerlof explained this phenomenon in his 1970 paper "The Market for Lemons" and won the Nobel Prize in Economics for this research. In the used car market, when sellers know more about car defects and prices become uniform, good cars disappear from the market and only defective vehicles (lemons) remain. The loan market is the same. When interest rates become uniform, good borrowers leave and only bad borrowers remain, increasing bank losses.
Third, actual data supports this. According to Bank of Korea data, the delinquency rate for borrowers with credit scores of 600 or below is about 8-12%, while the delinquency rate for borrowers with 900+ points is less than 0.5%. In other words, when lending to low-credit borrowers, the probability that banks won't get their money back is more than 10 times higher. If this risk isn't reflected in interest rates, bank profitability deteriorates rapidly, and eventually banks become troubled and depositors' money becomes at risk too. During the 2008 financial crisis, hundreds of banks went bankrupt in the U.S., and the government had to inject $700 billion in emergency bailout funds.
If information asymmetry and adverse selection are left unchecked, the entire financial system can collapse, so credit-based interest rate differentiation is essential.
✅ Past Financial Crisis Cases and Lessons
Let's analyze historical cases of how reckless low-interest lending led to financial crises.
First, the 2003 Korean credit card crisis shows the danger of indiscriminate credit provision. From the late 1990s to the early 2000s, card companies competitively increased credit card issuance. They issued cards recklessly without properly checking credit scores through "card issuance without income proof," "massive expansion of cash service limits," and "competition in points and discount benefits." As a result, as of the end of 2002, there were 43 million credit card holders (4.6 cards per adult), and card usage exceeded 500 trillion won annually. But from 2003, delinquency rates began to surge, and eventually 3.72 million people fell into credit default. Major card companies became troubled and the government had to inject 4 trillion won in public funds, and the domestic economy was greatly contracted.
Second, the 2008 U.S. subprime mortgage crisis was a disaster on a much larger scale. In the early to mid-2000s, U.S. banks gave home loans so recklessly that the term 'NINJA loans (No Income, No Job, No Asset: loans given to people with no income, job, or assets)' emerged. They gave low-interest loans even to subprime (non-prime) borrowers with credit scores below 600, relying on the optimism that "house prices will keep rising." Until 2006, house prices actually rose so there seemed to be no problem, but when house prices started falling from 2007, millions of people couldn't pay back their loans at the same time. This led to the bankruptcy of major financial companies like Lehman Brothers, and the global financial crisis exploded in September 2008. The U.S. government injected $700 billion in bailout funds, and global GDP recorded negative growth.
Third, the lesson from these cases is clear. In the short term, indiscriminate lending may seem to stimulate the economy and increase consumption. But in the medium to long term, bad loans accumulate and the entire system collapses, causing even greater damage. Financial crises aren't just problems for banks - they lead to increased unemployment, corporate bankruptcies, and real estate crashes, destroying the lives of millions of people. Therefore, low-interest lending that ignores credit scores can be a 'short-term painkiller' but can never be a 'long-term cure.' It can actually be poison that worsens the disease.
Historical cases show that credit-based interest rate differentiation isn't simply banks pursuing profits but an essential mechanism that protects financial stability.
✅ Individual Credit Management Strategies
So how can individuals manage their credit to receive low interest rate benefits? Let's look at practical methods.
First, you must never be late on credit card and loan payments. The most important factor in credit scores is 'repayment history.' Even one late payment can drop your credit score by dozens of points, and long-term delinquency can drop it by over 100 points. Especially for phone bills, card payments, and loan interest, it's good to set up automatic transfers before the due date. This prevents accidentally forgetting. If you suddenly don't have enough money, it's much better to contact the card company in advance and use methods like installment payments or revolving credit than being late.
Second, it's good to keep credit card usage below 30% of your limit. Credit rating agencies also consider 'credit card usage rate' important. For example, if your limit is 5 million won but you spend 4.5 million won every month, it's interpreted as a signal that "does this person lack money?" Even spending the same amount, if you raise your limit to 15 million won to lower the usage rate to 30%, your credit score can go up. Also, it's good to refrain from unnecessary card issuance. Having too many cards can be evaluated as a "potential debt risk."
Third, you must build a long-term consistent financial transaction history. Credit scores are difficult to raise rapidly in a short time. Meaningful changes appear only after at least 6 months to 1 year of faithful repayment history accumulates. Therefore, it's important to develop the habit of using cards even for small amounts and paying them back on time from a young age. Also, it helps to regularly check your credit score on NICE Credit Rating or Korea Credit Bureau websites and understand which factors affect your score. Checking your own credit score doesn't affect your score.
Credit management is an important wealth management tool that can bring tens of millions of won in interest savings in the long term, even if it requires short-term inconvenience.
4️⃣ Conclusion
Bank loan interest rates varying by credit score may seem unfair on the surface, but they are actually a rational mechanism that protects the entire financial system and prevents bigger crises.
Giving low interest rates to people with high credit scores is a reward for the signal that 'they paid back debts faithfully in the past, so they're likely to do so in the future.' Conversely, charging high interest rates to people with low credit scores is economic logic that says 'the risk of not getting money back is high, so we want compensation for that.' This isn't bank greed but market principles that balance risk and return.
What would happen if everyone got the same low interest rates? In the short term, low-credit borrowers seem to benefit, but soon adverse selection and moral hazard occur. People who can pay back money don't take loans, only people who have trouble paying rush in, and banks' bad loans increase rapidly. This is the terrible reality already experienced in the 2003 Korean credit card crisis and the 2008 U.S. subprime crisis.
More importantly, such crises don't end as just a bank problem. When financial institutions become troubled, lending stops, companies can't get funding and go bankrupt, unemployment increases, and real estate prices crash. Ultimately, financial crises paralyze the entire economy and destroy the lives of millions of people.
Therefore, from an individual's perspective, rather than complaining "my interest rate is high because my credit score is low," it's more productive to think "how can I raise my credit score to receive low interest rate benefits?" If you don't be late on credit cards and loans, keep card usage rate below 30%, and build faithful financial transaction history long-term, anyone can improve their credit score.
A 100-point credit score difference creates a 1-2% loan interest rate difference, and for a 100 million won loan, this results in an annual interest difference of 1-2 million won. For a 30-year home mortgage, this can make a difference of tens of millions of won. Therefore, credit management is one of the most certain wealth management tools.
In the end, credit-based interest rate differentiation may be inconvenient personally, but it's an essential system that protects society's overall financial stability and prevents bigger crises. Understanding this system and actively managing your credit is a wise choice that benefits both individuals and the overall economy.
Table of Contents