🚨 Industrial Accident Insurance Cartel

Today Korean Social News for Beginners | 2025.10.22

0️⃣ Fraud Allegations and Systematic Collusion Controversy

📌 Ministry of Labor: "Taking Active Measures Against Overseas Job Scam Ads... 'No Industrial Accident Insurance Cartel'"

💬 During the National Assembly audit of the Ministry of Employment and Labor, both the job scam problem in Cambodia and Southeast Asia and allegations of an "industrial accident insurance cartel" became major issues. Regarding the investigation into the industrial accident insurance cartel ordered by former President Yoon Suk-yeol, the Ministry of Labor stated that "it was not a case of organized collusion." They explained that there were no arrests or criminal charges filed, and only simple fraud cases were found. Meanwhile, regarding overseas job scams, they announced plans to block fake job advertisements by designating words like "high income" and "Cambodia" as forbidden terms and cooperating with private platforms. This controversy has raised public interest in the transparency and oversight of the workers' compensation insurance system.

💡 Summary

• Industrial accident insurance cartel means systematic collusion among stakeholders within the workers' compensation system to fraudulently receive benefits.
• The Ministry of Labor investigated following former President Yoon Suk-yeol's order but stated no organized cartel was found.
• Concerns about insurance fraud and the need to strengthen oversight systems remain.

1️⃣ Definition

Industrial accident insurance cartel refers to systematic collusion where companies, medical institutions, legal representatives, and examination agencies informally work together within the industrial accident compensation insurance system to fraudulently receive insurance benefits or abuse the system for profit. Cartel originally means in economics when companies collude to manipulate prices or divide markets, but this term is used critically to describe abnormal profit-sharing structures within the workers' compensation insurance system.

Workers' compensation insurance is a social insurance system to compensate workers for work-related injuries. Employers pay all insurance premiums, and the Korea Workers' Compensation & Welfare Service manages the system. However, cases of fraudulently receiving insurance money through fake medical certificates, excessive treatment, and false reporting have raised questions about the system's reliability.

💡 Why is this important?

• Workers' compensation insurance is a key social safety net for protecting workers, so trust in the system is very important.
• Insurance fraud increases the insurance premium burden on honest companies and threatens the system's sustainability.
• It can prevent workers who truly need help from properly exercising their legitimate rights.
• It is a serious problem that damages the fairness and trust of society as a whole.

2️⃣ Background and Current Status of the Controversy

📕 Start and Progress of the Investigation

• The investigation began following former President Yoon Suk-yeol's order. The main background is as follows:

  • In 2024, former President Yoon Suk-yeol pointed out suspicions of insurance fraud and collusion within the workers' compensation system.
  • Allegations were raised that some companies, medical institutions, and legal representatives were colluding to illegally obtain workers' compensation insurance money.
  • A full investigation of the Ministry of Labor and the Korea Workers' Compensation & Welfare Service was ordered.
  • Criticisms were made that the approval rate for industrial accidents was too high and the review process was not transparent.

• Investigation results showed no organized cartel was found. The main findings are as follows:

  • The Ministry of Labor stated in the parliamentary audit that "there were no arrests or criminal charges."
  • They explained that simple fraud cases were found but there was no evidence of systematic collusion.
  • Some individual cases such as excessive treatment or fake medical certificate writing were discovered.
  • The government's official position is that "it was not organized collusion that could be called a cartel."

📕 Reality of Insurance Fraud

• Various forms of insurance fraud are occurring. The main types are as follows:

  • Medical institutions write fake medical certificates or provide excessive treatment.
  • Employers and workers agree to report injuries unrelated to work as industrial accidents.
  • Legal representatives manipulate or exaggerate evidence to receive excessive compensation.
  • People pretend to have worked and receive insurance money even though they didn't actually work.

• Detection and recovery of fraudulent claims are receiving attention. The main statistics are as follows:

  • The Korea Workers' Compensation & Welfare Service conducts annual checks on fraudulent claims and recovers hundreds of billions of won.
  • As of 2023, about 30 billion won or more in fraudulent claims were detected.
  • However, the actual scale of insurance fraud is estimated to be much larger.
  • There are many blind spots that go undetected, making system improvements urgent.

💡 Main Issues in the Industrial Accident Insurance Cartel Controversy

1. Whether organized collusion exists: Disagreement over whether a systematic cartel exists
2. Scale of fraud: Need to accurately understand how much insurance fraud exists
3. Insufficient oversight: Limitations in the examination and oversight capabilities of the Korea Workers' Compensation & Welfare Service
4. System loopholes: Need to improve system weaknesses that can be exploited
5. Stakeholder responsibility: Unclear responsibility of medical institutions, legal representatives, and companies

3️⃣ System Improvement Plans and Response Tasks

✅ Improvement Efforts by the Korea Workers' Compensation & Welfare Service

• Strengthening the examination and oversight system. The main measures are as follows:

  • Expanding detailed investigations of suspicious cases during the industrial accident examination process.
  • Introducing a fraud detection system using artificial intelligence and big data.
  • Strengthening monitoring of medical institutions and legal representatives.
  • Pursuing strict recovery measures and criminal charges when fraud is detected.

• Working to increase transparency and fairness. The main contents are as follows:

  • Clarifying and publicizing industrial accident examination standards to increase predictability.
  • Operating a review committee with participation by outside experts.
  • Improving the objection filing process to help with legitimate rights relief.
  • Activating channels where citizens can report insurance fraud.

✅ Role of Government and National Assembly

• Improvement of laws and systems is needed. The main tasks are as follows:

  • The Industrial Accident Compensation Insurance Act should be revised to strengthen punishment for fraud.
  • Regulations are needed to clarify the responsibilities of medical institutions and legal representatives.
  • The investigation authority and personnel of the Korea Workers' Compensation & Welfare Service should be expanded.
  • A protection and compensation system for fraud whistleblowers should be established.

• Social awareness improvement and education are important. The main approaches are as follows:

  • The awareness that workers' compensation insurance is for workers who truly need it should be spread.
  • People should be informed that insurance fraud ultimately becomes a burden on all citizens.
  • Both employers and workers should be educated on how to use the system properly.
  • Efforts are needed to raise the ethical consciousness of medical institutions and legal representatives.

4️⃣ Related Terms Explained

🔎 Industrial Accident Compensation Insurance Act

• This is the basic legal basis for workers' compensation insurance.
  • The Industrial Accident Compensation Insurance Act is a law to provide quick and fair compensation when workers suffer work-related injuries. Enacted in 1964 and revised several times since, employers bear all insurance premiums and the Korea Workers' Compensation & Welfare Service acts as the insurer and pays benefits.
  • The main types of benefits include: First, medical care benefits to cover treatment costs. Second, temporary disability benefits to compensate for income loss during treatment. Third, disability benefits to compensate for permanent disabilities. Fourth, survivors' benefits paid to families when workers die. Fifth, additional benefits such as nursing care benefits and funeral expenses.
  • For insurance fraud, violators can be punished under the Industrial Accident Insurance Act separately from fraud under criminal law. If someone receives benefits through false reporting or document forgery, they face up to 5 years in prison or a fine of up to 50 million won, and up to 5 times the received benefits can be collected. The industrial accident insurance cartel controversy started from suspicions that cases of exploiting these system loopholes were occurring systematically.

🔎 Cartel

• Market distortion through collusion and monopoly.
  • A cartel is originally an economics term, referring to actions where companies in the same industry collude to restrict competition and control the market by fixing prices, production volumes, and sales regions. The Fair Trade Act prohibits this as unfair joint action, and when caught, penalties up to 10% of sales can be imposed.
  • General characteristics of cartels include: First, multiple parties collude to pursue common interests. Second, they harm consumers by hindering normal competition. Third, they are often done secretly, making detection difficult. Fourth, while beneficial to participants in the short term, they distort the entire market in the long term.
  • The term "industrial accident insurance cartel" metaphorically applies this economic cartel concept to the social system area. It expresses suspicions that companies, medical institutions, legal representatives, and agency officials collude to share profits through insurance fraud, but organized collusion has not actually been proven. However, this term serves to remind people of structural problems within the workers' compensation system and the need for improvements.

🔎 Korea Workers' Compensation & Welfare Service

• The public agency that directly operates workers' compensation insurance.
  • The Korea Workers' Compensation & Welfare Service is a quasi-governmental organization under the Ministry of Employment and Labor, responsible for collecting and paying benefits for workers' compensation insurance and employment insurance. Established in 1995, it has about 100 branches nationwide. In addition to workers' compensation insurance, it operates various worker welfare programs such as worker welfare facilities and vocational rehabilitation support.
  • The Service's main tasks include: First, managing workers' compensation insurance enrollment and collecting premiums. Second, receiving industrial accident applications and examining whether injuries are work-related. Third, paying various benefits and post-management. Fourth, designating and managing medical care institutions. Fifth, investigating and recovering fraudulent claims.
  • After the industrial accident insurance cartel controversy, the Service was criticized that its internal review procedures became too cautious. This is because the number of cases where legitimate industrial accidents were denied increased, raising workers' complaints. The Service's position is that a balanced approach is needed to maintain proper review standards while strictly filtering out insurance fraud. It is also working to improve the accuracy and efficiency of reviews by introducing artificial intelligence systems and expanding specialized personnel.

5️⃣ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: Does the industrial accident insurance cartel actually exist?

A: Organized collusion has not been proven, but the need for system improvements is clear.

• According to the Ministry of Labor's investigation results, since there were no arrests or criminal charges, systematic collusion that could be called a "cartel" was not confirmed. First, some individual fraud cases were found but there was no evidence of organized collusion. Second, no evidence emerged that medical institutions, legal representatives, and companies systematically conspired. Third, while fraud detection cases existed in the past, it's difficult to see this as developing into a cartel.
• However, even if the term "cartel" was somewhat exaggerated, it is true that parts of the workers' compensation system need improvement. Tasks that should be continuously pursued include strengthening oversight to prevent fraud, establishing transparent review standards, and clarifying responsibility regulations for stakeholders. What's important is finding a balance so that workers who truly need help can be properly protected while preventing insurance fraud.

Q: What efforts are being made to prevent workers' compensation insurance fraud?

A: Multiple inspections and technology adoption are being used to block fraud.

• The Korea Workers' Compensation & Welfare Service and the government are making fraud prevention efforts in many areas. First, they are building a fraud detection system using big data and artificial intelligence. They automatically find suspicious patterns to select targets for detailed investigation. Second, they are strengthening on-site inspections of medical institutions. They intensively investigate institutions suspected of excessive treatment or fake medical certificate writing. Third, they monitor the activities of legal representatives and detect improper cases. Fourth, they operate a citizen reporting center to receive tips about insurance fraud.
• Also, strict measures are taken against detected fraud. Not only is the full fraudulent amount recovered, but up to 5 times the amount can be collected, and criminal charges are also filed. For medical institutions, penalties such as canceling their designation as medical care institutions or restricting benefit claims for a certain period are possible. For these efforts to be effective, continuous system improvements along with the interest and cooperation of all members of society are needed.

Table of Contents

• Go to Guide